Book Hotels Shelter Island
Shelter Island
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

Shelter Island

Nov 03 - Nov 04 ·
2 guests

Shelter Island Hotels

Shelter Island
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

Navigation

1. The Pridwin Hotel

2. Sunset Beach

3. New Haven Hotel

4. Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

Cheap Hotels

5. Montauk Manor

6. Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

7. Old Town Inn

Pet Friendly Hotels

8. La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area

9. Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area

10. Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury

  • Private beach
The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road
3.1 km (1.9 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Steam room
  • Pool with view

Located 3.5 km from East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation, the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island offers access to tourist attractions throughout Shelter Island. The hotel boasts a waterfront location featuring an outdoor swimming pool and an American restaurant.

A popular place in Shelter Island is Mashomack Preserve, which is around 10 minutes' drive away.

8.5
61 reviews
~ US$334 / night

The Pridwin Hotel

3.1 km (1.9 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Steam room
  • Pool with view

The Pridwin Hotel

Located 3.5 km from East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation, the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island offers access to tourist attractions throughout Shelter Island. The hotel boasts a waterfront location featuring an outdoor swimming pool and an American restaurant.

A popular place in Shelter Island is Mashomack Preserve, which is around 10 minutes' drive away.

8.5
61 reviews
From US$ 334 / night
  • Top location
Sunset Beach Sunset Beach

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road
2.3 km (1.5 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Luggage storage
  • Golf centre

The 4-star Sunset Beach Shelter Island hotel is within a 10-minute drive of Beall & Bell Antique Store and features 24-hour desk and wake-up service.

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation is approximately 3 km from the hotel, while Hampton Bays is 21 km away. This Shelter Island hotel is also right near Sunset Beach.

8.2
8 reviews
~ US$596 / night

Sunset Beach

2.3 km (1.5 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Luggage storage
  • Golf centre

Sunset Beach

The 4-star Sunset Beach Shelter Island hotel is within a 10-minute drive of Beall & Bell Antique Store and features 24-hour desk and wake-up service.

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation is approximately 3 km from the hotel, while Hampton Bays is 21 km away. This Shelter Island hotel is also right near Sunset Beach.

8.2
8 reviews
From US$ 596 / night

Hotels near Shelter Island

  • Great deal
New Haven Hotel New Haven Hotel

New Haven Hotel

229 George Street
56.0 km (34.8 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Car park
    US$ 24 per day
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Luggage storage
  • Fitness centre
8.4
1865 reviews
~ US$63 / night

New Haven Hotel

56.0 km (34.8 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Car park
    US$ 24 per day
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Luggage storage
  • Fitness centre

New Haven Hotel

8.4
1865 reviews
From US$ 63 / night

Cheap Hotels

  • Guest favorite
Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

2049 Norwich-New London Turnpike
50.2 km (31.2 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool
8.6
1634 reviews
~ US$109 / night

Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

50.2 km (31.2 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

8.6
1634 reviews
From US$ 109 / night
Montauk Manor Montauk Manor

Montauk Manor

236 Edgemere Street
32.7 km (20.3 mi) from Shelter Island
  • BBQ facilities
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

The 5-star smoke-free Montauk Manor Hotel, located about a 10-minute drive from Fort Pond Bay Park, offers a swimming pool and Wi-Fi in public areas. With the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach approximately 3 km away, this Montauk hotel offers 3 outdoor tennis courts for the best experience.

You can visit Lake Montauk that is around a 15-minute ride from the hotel. Options for cultural tourism include Second House Museum, situated 3.6 km away.

9
1237 reviews
~ US$157 / night

Montauk Manor

32.7 km (20.3 mi) from Shelter Island
  • BBQ facilities
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

Montauk Manor

The 5-star smoke-free Montauk Manor Hotel, located about a 10-minute drive from Fort Pond Bay Park, offers a swimming pool and Wi-Fi in public areas. With the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach approximately 3 km away, this Montauk hotel offers 3 outdoor tennis courts for the best experience.

You can visit Lake Montauk that is around a 15-minute ride from the hotel. Options for cultural tourism include Second House Museum, situated 3.6 km away.

9
1237 reviews
From US$ 157 / night
  • Eco-friendly stay
Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

5 Watson Road
55.9 km (34.7 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool
8.8
915 reviews
~ US$119 / night

Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

55.9 km (34.7 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods

8.8
915 reviews
From US$ 119 / night

Pet Friendly Hotels

  • Best-rated
Old Town Inn Old Town Inn

Old Town Inn

508 Old Town Road
64.8 km (40.3 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Leisure/ TV room
  • Tennis court
  • Sun terrace

Set overlooking the garden, the comfortable Old Town Inn New Shoreham features a sunbathing terrace and a picnic area. Located within a 10-minute drive of Mohegan Bluffs Cliff, the hotel features 24-hour security service.

Attractions, 3.5 km from this New Shoreham hotel, include Settler's Rock Reef.

9.6
212 reviews
~ US$155 / night

Old Town Inn

64.8 km (40.3 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Leisure/ TV room
  • Tennis court
  • Sun terrace

Old Town Inn

Set overlooking the garden, the comfortable Old Town Inn New Shoreham features a sunbathing terrace and a picnic area. Located within a 10-minute drive of Mohegan Bluffs Cliff, the hotel features 24-hour security service.

Attractions, 3.5 km from this New Shoreham hotel, include Settler's Rock Reef.

9.6
212 reviews
From US$ 155 / night
  • Beach access
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area

La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area

349 Liberty Street
55.2 km (34.3 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool
8.6
415 reviews
~ US$79 / night

La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area

55.2 km (34.3 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area

8.6
415 reviews
From US$ 79 / night
Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area

Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area

2255 Norwich New London Turnpike
50.6 km (31.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Live entertainment
  • Indoor swimming pool

The 3-star Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area, located 19 minutes on foot from the American Mohegan Sun Casino, offers guests a lift and a vending machine.

You'll find Norwich Golf Course merely 1.9 km from this Uncasville hotel. Feel in total harmony with nature by visiting Stoddard Hill State Park Scenic Reserve, approximately 10 minutes by car from the smoke-free hotel.

8.6
480 reviews
~ US$99 / night

Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area

50.6 km (31.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Live entertainment
  • Indoor swimming pool

Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area

The 3-star Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area, located 19 minutes on foot from the American Mohegan Sun Casino, offers guests a lift and a vending machine.

You'll find Norwich Golf Course merely 1.9 km from this Uncasville hotel. Feel in total harmony with nature by visiting Stoddard Hill State Park Scenic Reserve, approximately 10 minutes by car from the smoke-free hotel.

8.6
480 reviews
From US$ 99 / night

Dog Friendly Hotels

  • Eco-friendly stay
Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury

Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury

85 Glastonbury Boulevard
76.5 km (47.5 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool

Located nearly 20 minutes' walk from Welles-Turner Memorial Library, the 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury includes 148 rooms. Boasting a swimming pool, this Glastonbury inn also offers a vending machine and a lift, which provide additional comfort.

The hotel is 3.8 km from Pratt & Whitney Hangar Museum and 95 km from Southampton. Somerset Square Shopping Center is just 5 minutes' walk away.

9.3
3 reviews
~ US$113 / night

Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury

76.5 km (47.5 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool

Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury

Located nearly 20 minutes' walk from Welles-Turner Memorial Library, the 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury includes 148 rooms. Boasting a swimming pool, this Glastonbury inn also offers a vending machine and a lift, which provide additional comfort.

The hotel is 3.8 km from Pratt & Whitney Hangar Museum and 95 km from Southampton. Somerset Square Shopping Center is just 5 minutes' walk away.

9.3
3 reviews
From US$ 113 / night
  • Popular choice
Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino

Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino

411 Norwich Westerly Rd
56.1 km (34.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool

The 3-star smoke-free Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino North Stonington, located nearly a 10-minute drive from Hoffman Evergreen Preserve, boasts a heated indoor pool and a fitness centre. With the expansive Mashantucket Pequot Museum and Research Center approximately 6 km away, this North Stonington inn offers two jacuzzis for the best experience.

Guests will also get to the hotel around a 15-minute ride from the ascending trails "Lantern Hill".

8.1
2601 reviews
~ US$144 / night

Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino

56.1 km (34.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool

Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino

The 3-star smoke-free Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino North Stonington, located nearly a 10-minute drive from Hoffman Evergreen Preserve, boasts a heated indoor pool and a fitness centre. With the expansive Mashantucket Pequot Museum and Research Center approximately 6 km away, this North Stonington inn offers two jacuzzis for the best experience.

Guests will also get to the hotel around a 15-minute ride from the ascending trails "Lantern Hill".

8.1
2601 reviews
From US$ 144 / night
Hyatt Place Mystic Hyatt Place Mystic

Hyatt Place Mystic

224 Greenmanville Ave
46.2 km (28.7 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

The 3-star smoke-free Hyatt Place Mystic hotel is a great place in a popular area of Mystic, which stands approximately a 5-minute walk from the performing arts theater "Cornerstone Playhouse". Located in proximity to the - art Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration, this perfect hotel features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool for guests to relax in.

Mystic centre can be reached within 25 minutes' walk. Morgan Point Light is 4.6 km away, while Coogan Farm Nature and Heritage Center is 500 metres from the Hyatt Mystic. You can also visit Mystic River Bascule Bridge, nearly 10 minutes away by car, as well as enjoy golf courses and restaurants within walking distance of this hotel. The property offers close proximity to Fields Of Fire Adventure Park Recreation Center, which is located 3 km away and helps strengthen mental and physical health. Hyatt Place Mystic hotel is within 25 minutes' walk of Mystic rail station.

8.6
522 reviews
~ US$114 / night

Hyatt Place Mystic

46.2 km (28.7 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

Hyatt Place Mystic

The 3-star smoke-free Hyatt Place Mystic hotel is a great place in a popular area of Mystic, which stands approximately a 5-minute walk from the performing arts theater "Cornerstone Playhouse". Located in proximity to the - art Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration, this perfect hotel features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool for guests to relax in.

Mystic centre can be reached within 25 minutes' walk. Morgan Point Light is 4.6 km away, while Coogan Farm Nature and Heritage Center is 500 metres from the Hyatt Mystic. You can also visit Mystic River Bascule Bridge, nearly 10 minutes away by car, as well as enjoy golf courses and restaurants within walking distance of this hotel. The property offers close proximity to Fields Of Fire Adventure Park Recreation Center, which is located 3 km away and helps strengthen mental and physical health. Hyatt Place Mystic hotel is within 25 minutes' walk of Mystic rail station.

8.6
522 reviews
From US$ 114 / night

Kid Friendly Hotels

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg

2104 N. Broad Street
66.8 km (41.5 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool
8.7
301 reviews
~ US$99 / night

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg

66.8 km (41.5 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg

8.7
301 reviews
From US$ 99 / night
  • Eco-friendly stay
Hilton Mystic Hilton Mystic

Hilton Mystic

20 Coogan Boulevard
46.6 km (29.0 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Car park
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Live entertainment
  • Heated swimming pool

The 4-star Hilton Mystic Hotel, located within 20 minutes' walk of Denison Homestead Museum, offers a heated pool and Wi-Fi throughout the property. The hotel is within walking distance of many of the attractions including the - art Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration and Foxwoods Marine Theater.

Guests can find Mystic Knotwork Store 2.3 km from this hotel. The Hilton lies around 25 minutes' walk from the recreated 19th-century coastal village "Mystic Seaport Museum". The nearest train station, Mystic, is 2.4 km away.

8.5
622 reviews
~ US$119 / night

Hilton Mystic

46.6 km (29.0 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Car park
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Live entertainment
  • Heated swimming pool

Hilton Mystic

The 4-star Hilton Mystic Hotel, located within 20 minutes' walk of Denison Homestead Museum, offers a heated pool and Wi-Fi throughout the property. The hotel is within walking distance of many of the attractions including the - art Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration and Foxwoods Marine Theater.

Guests can find Mystic Knotwork Store 2.3 km from this hotel. The Hilton lies around 25 minutes' walk from the recreated 19th-century coastal village "Mystic Seaport Museum". The nearest train station, Mystic, is 2.4 km away.

8.5
622 reviews
From US$ 119 / night
Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area

Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area

1954 Norwich New London Tpke
49.7 km (30.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Laundry
  • Tea and coffee facilities

Situated approximately 7 km from the J. F. Slater Memorial Museum, the smoke-free Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area features Wi-Fi in public areas and a car park on site.

Sights around 10 minutes' drive from this 3-star hotel include the performing arts theater "Cabaret Theatre". Along with other cultural attractions Samson Occom Bridge is nestled 2.4 km from the hotel.

7.9
1511 reviews
~ US$99 / night

Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area

49.7 km (30.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Laundry
  • Tea and coffee facilities

Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area

Situated approximately 7 km from the J. F. Slater Memorial Museum, the smoke-free Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area features Wi-Fi in public areas and a car park on site.

Sights around 10 minutes' drive from this 3-star hotel include the performing arts theater "Cabaret Theatre". Along with other cultural attractions Samson Occom Bridge is nestled 2.4 km from the hotel.

7.9
1511 reviews
From US$ 99 / night

Hotels Downtown

  • Eco-friendly stay
Home2 Suites By Hilton East Haven New Haven Home2 Suites By Hilton East Haven New Haven

Home2 Suites By Hilton East Haven New Haven

30 Frontage Road
51.1 km (31.8 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool
9.1
352 reviews
~ US$153 / night

Home2 Suites By Hilton East Haven New Haven

51.1 km (31.8 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor swimming pool

Home2 Suites By Hilton East Haven New Haven

9.1
352 reviews
From US$ 153 / night

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
The Pridwin Hotel

8.5 / 10

(61 Reviews)

From 334$
Sunset Beach

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

From 596$
New Haven Hotel

8.4 / 10

(1865 Reviews)

From 63$
Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area

8.6 / 10

(1634 Reviews)

From 109$
Montauk Manor

9.0 / 10

(1237 Reviews)

From 157$

Location